POSTED BY Sundeep ON Mar 08, 2010 AT 22:08 IST ,  Edited At: Mar 09, 2010 22:08 IST

From CNN-IBN's Devil Advocate, Karan Thapar inteviews Javed Akhtar: 

Karan Thapar: Today, Husain says he has complete freedom in Qatar. As you see things, is Qatar a better guardian of freedom of expression than India?

Javed Akhtar: You see, Husain has not gone to Qatar. I don't remember the title of the story (but) Camus, in one of his short stories, has written that the master tells the servant, "I am going away from here now" and the servant says, "Where are you going master?" and he says, "Can't you understand? I am going away from here. That's where I am going." Husain has not gone to Qatar. Husain has gone away from India....

Karan Thapar: I want to come back and talk to you about the other lady who raises the same fundamental question: Taslima Nasreen. Javed Akhtar, let's come to Taslima Nasreen and the article that created so much controversy, which was originally written for outlook magazine in 2007. Taslima Nasreen writes that the Burqa, Hijab, the Chaadar and headscarf are instruments of disrespect. She adds, these are symbols of women's oppression. Even if you do not agree with her, it is really such an offensive thing to say?

Javed Akhtar: You know, please allow me to digress a little. Till now we are talking about the Hindu fanatics and the Hindu fundamentalists. Now, we are talking about the Muslim fundamentalists. And their resemblance and similarities is uncanny. It reminds me, you know, some four hundred and fifty years back when Tulsidas wrote Ram Charit Manas in Awadhi, he was disowned by the Brahmin community and he had become an outcast. They were upset with him that how can he write a story like Ramayana in a language like Awadhi?

Such an ordinary, common man's language. It is an insult to Ramayana and some two hundred years back, in the same very city Delhi, Shah Abdul Kadir, a gentleman, for the first time, translated Quran in Urdu in 1798 and all the Ulemas of that time gave the fatwa against him that how dare he translate Quran in such a heathen and such a perverse language. So, you see that these people, their minds function in the same way. People who are against Husain are a mirror image of the people who are against Taslima Nasreen.

Read the full transcript here

POSTED BY Sundeep ON Mar 08, 2010 AT 22:08 IST ,  Edited At: Mar 09, 2010 22:08 IST
Follow us on Twitter for all updates, like us on Facebook for important and fun stuff
TRANSLATE INTO:


Post a Comment
Share your thoughts
You are not logged in, please log in or register
Must See
Daily Mail
Digression
42/D-83
Mar 18, 2010
02:48 PM
Excellent interview and for one of the very few times the discussions and comments have been cogent and mostly civil and to the point.

Keep it up
Atul Chandra
mUMBAI, INDIA
41/D-117
Mar 14, 2010
10:34 PM
dear sandilya
welcome back. missed u and rejuvenated by ur comments and treatment advice.
caste is a reality dear friend and the opinions on various issues too vary depending upon which gender/nation/religion /caste u belong too and even in this except caste all others can be changed.
ganapathi
chennai, India
40/D-98
Mar 14, 2010
05:56 PM
Ganapathi

Some time back I said you cannot write one sentence without recourse to caste. I am yet to see a post sans caste. Every post of yours stinks of caste and more caste. Aren't you ashamed to be so caste conscious? That is exactly what you accuse the Brahmins of.

My wild guess is that you are suffering from an incurable disease called 'Dalitosis Stupidensitis'.

If you have insurance seek some psychiatric counselling, for your extreme obsession with caste which is nothing but fanaticism.
I see you as an antinational.
sandilya
Chennai, India
39/D-97
Mar 14, 2010
05:44 PM
Lalit to Kumar

>> imagine a hindu artist in pakistan painting
mehemmet in the nude along with his 13 wives and numerous concubines. all hell would break lose from lahore to algier.

Hi Lalit, how do u do? I did not know you were in Chennai. Being busy I was not regular in this forum for a long time.
Nice to read your post after a long time. All that you have said I fully agree.

You said about painting of Mohammed and his wives. Even if somebody painted it the way you have described it would still conform only to the factual account of Mohammed . No real distortion except that depicting Mohammed in picture is offensive to Islam.

Whereas, Husain painted Sita in nude on the tail of Hanuman. These two epic figures are sacred and seen by Hindus as mother and son equivalent. Depicting a mother in nude is poor in taste and abhorring by any standard, to hell with that crap called artistic freedom etc, which the secular blokes keep parroting to defend the undefendable.
I know they defend as long as their mothers are not painted in nude. Hope Kumar got the message. Otherwise we may have to ask Husain to paint Kumar's mother in nude and then ask him how much he liked it?
sandilya
Chennai, India
38/D-115
Mar 13, 2010
04:23 PM
I agree that the enlightened public space is shrinking. However, I believe that Swapan tends to generalize it too much. We have no evidence if this public space ever included Muslims (or even other non-Hindu religions).
whats in a name
dear friend
how come u generalise hindus.r they brahmins or jats or mahars. what similarity is there between a tamil dalit and a kashmiri pandit or a punjabi hindu. i am more comfortable with a kalam or a vijay amirtaraj and prefer to have a fellow tamil/mallu/kannadiga/marathi has a room mate when working/studying in northindia/abroad.
why only hindus from certain castes in north kill their own sisters/daughters in dozen evry day for falling in love. does it show the compassion of hinduism.
i am amazed by the attempts by many in this forum to create a hindu opinion which never exists. whether its mayawathi or a dalit mason his views on hussain paintings will be miles apart from that of a kashmiri pandit or rajasthan rajput.kindly see nepal which was the only hindu country and when the atheists increase in number the country becomes secular. its not the pandits from south india who were enjoying absolute reservation who wanted secularism but the group which thrashed them. indian secularism owes itself entirely to the downtrodden majority who care very little for religion
ganapathi
chennai, India
Order by
Order by
Short Takes
recent tags
Cricket
Cricket - BCCI
Cricket - IPL
Elections
Harsha Bhogle
Incredible India
Mahendra Singh Dhoni
Mukul Kesavan
N. Srinivasan
Pakistan Politics
Pakistan: Polls
Police & Security Forces
Ravi Shastri
Sriram Srinivasan
Sunil Gavaskar
Taliban
Uttar Pradesh
 
bloggers
A. Sanzgiri
Boria Majumdar
Buzz
Dr Mohammad Taqi
Freya Dasgupta
G. Rajaraman
K.V. Bapa Rao
Namrata Joshi
News Ed
Omar Ali
Our Readers Write Back
Prarthna Gahilote
Shefalee Vasudev
Sundeep Dougal
ARCHIVES
Go
SMTWTFS
1234
567891011
12131415161718
19202122232425
262728293031
recent comments


ABOUT US | CONTACT US | SUBSCRIBE | ADVERTISING RATES | COPYRIGHT & DISCLAIMER | COMMENTS POLICY

OUTLOOK TOPICS:    a b c d e f g h i j k l m n o p q r s t u v w x y z  0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9   
Or just type in a few initial letters of a topic: