Follow us:
POSTED BY Sundeep Dougal ON Jan 31, 2012 AT 23:43 IST ,  Edited At: Jan 31, 2012 23:43 IST

First, ABVP goons managed to prevent Sanjay Kak's documentary Jashn-e-Azadi from being screened at Pune's Symbiosis University — ironically known for its communications department. And then, today, the seminar that was proposed to be held instead, ‘Speaking about Kashmir ’, where the blocked documentary's maker Sanjay Kak was to speak, was also "postponed".

While the muscle-flexing by the BJP's student wing and Panun Kashmir was blatant, the university authorities now claim that they have not cravenly caved in to the ABVP fatwa -- they now cite, just as the organisers of JLF did, the fear of violence and the advice of Police of the ‘secular’ Congress-NCP government in Maharashtra , and claim that the seminar has only been "postponed" and not cancelled.

On Hardnews, Sanjay Kak tells Amit Sengupta:

See, this film is almost 5 years old, and is freely available on the internet. Thousands of people can see it all over the country and around the globe. I don't think the idea of a screening in a seminar that is threatening to them. I think it is the idea that a real conversation about Kashmir is happening in a mainstream educational  institution, that this conversation is getting the legitimacy it deserves -- that I think is what is scary for them. And not just for the ABVP, please let us remember. It is scary for all those who have all these years prevented a genuine debate about Kashmir in India . Rightwing, Leftwing, Centrist, whatever...

But the fight to be able to speak our minds freely is a continuous one, and as a documentary filmmaker, I'm aware that there will be no rest on this one issue. The ABVP in Pune is only one of the many forces that threaten that freedom... If educational institutions are going to be terrorised into limiting what they can -- or  cannot -- offer their students, then it is obviously something with serious implications. 

No matter what one thinks of Sanjay Kak's film, or however slanted it is seen to be -- and of course it is slanted -- seeking to suppress or ban it cannot possibly be a viable -- or even a smart -- response to it for those who don't want its ideas to be propagated. Because of the controversy -- as all censors and banners of things always find out to their dismay -- just as in the case of the Satanic Verses recently, the Streisand Effect is at play, and as many have pointed out, the controversy has only resulted in more people looking for the film online. Which is perhaps all for the better, for it is only when one knows what is being said that it can be engaged with -- debated, discussed, or even countered and demolished.

At the same time, as writer Hari Kunzru pointed out on Twitter (it's storified below), "Metropolitan India needs to open eyes to Kashmir" and "surely, if members of a national army have committed atrocities, it's patriotic to expose & punish them, for honor of nation." But that was only after pointing out "major flaws (eg no Pandit voices, lack of context)" and questioning "erasing KP's from story" and calling it "weak". And he's only stating the obvious when he says that  "there ought to be 10 films, 20 films, teasing out complexities, challenging prejudices. More light, less heat."

Why not just face the various complexities of Kashmir for what they are instead of trying to brush them under the carpet? It's only then that the issue of Pandits can also be addressed with honesty and clarity. And it's only then that one can actually truly try and understand what everybody there -- and that includes the armymen as well -- goes through on a daily basis. There is no bravery in gagging a film-maker, however much one may disagree with him. But dealing with the reality -- the truth -- of Kashmir and its various facets does require at least some commonsense and willingness to engage.

POSTED BY Sundeep Dougal ON Jan 31, 2012 AT 23:43 IST ,  Edited At: Jan 31, 2012 23:43 IST
Follow us on Twitter for all updates, like us on Facebook for important and fun stuff
TRANSLATE INTO:


Post a Comment
Share your thoughts
You are not logged in, please log in or register
Must See
Daily Mail
Digression
29/D-108
Jun 07, 2012
07:56 PM

>> "As far as the distinctiveness of Kashmir goes, it is in evidence in every single aspect of Kashmiri culture .. in

...... cuisine, in language, in religion and even in its climate. " - Pankaj

In case of cuisine and language, every state is distinct. wrt climate, we will have a decently wide grouping. That leaves us with religion - and that is the root cause of the Kashmir problem.

The Irreverent Indian
Online, India
28/D-98
Jun 07, 2012
07:18 PM

Varun Shekhar:

"There's nothing all that unique about Kashmir, except in the minds of the rabid separatists."

Except that those rabid separatists are in an overwhelming majority in the state. As far as the distinctiveness of Kashmir goes, it is in evidence in every single aspect of Kashmiri culture .. in cuisine, in language, in religion and even in its climate. One has to be blind, deaf and incredibly dumb to think otherwise.

Pankaj Vaishnavi
London, United Kingdom
27/D-24
Mar 03, 2012
05:14 AM

"The state has always been an adjunct part of the Indian subcontinent, geographically remote and culturally different and the entire population of the state is around 4 million odd. Most Indians won't even know it if it actually happened."

  There's nothing all that unique about Kashmir, except in the minds of the rabid separatists. Conceding the area would be a highly regressive and dangerous move, because it would strengthen the hands of the Islamists, the Pakistani military and Al-Qaeda. And would embolden them in their goal of spreading Islamism.

Varun Shekhar
Toronto, CANADA
26/D-136
Feb 13, 2012
06:58 PM

Akshay:

 "The last time we tried that bright idea it resulted in millions of dead people..."

The last time we tried that idea, we failed in properly executing it. India was a nascent state, with an under-developed state machinery to enforce law and order necessary for large-scale population transfers.

Besides, a plebescite in J&K is not even analogous to India's partition because no Indian owns (or can own) land there - so there won't be any population transfer. The state has always been an adjunct part of the Indian subcontinent, geographically remote and culturally different and the entire population of the state is around 4 million odd. Most Indians won't even know it if it actually happened.

Pankaj Vaishnavi
London, United Kingdom
6/D-77
Feb 07, 2012
02:16 PM

The Kashmiri Muslims are so well fed,well clothed and well housed,using Hindu tax payer's money.Still they don't stand up and fight for the return of Kashmiri Pandits.Compare a photograph of the poverty stricken Hindus of Orissa(Odisha) with that of a common Kashmiri Muslim as to how in the name of secularism the Sonia-Manmohan gang ignore the Hindu poor and limitlessly feed the Kashmiri Muslims.When,Ghulam Nabi Azad was the CM,Manmohan Singh sanctioned a mammoth amount of 24,000 crores for such a small population.What happened to that money?Who is enjoying that?During the same period when the Orissa CM requested for special sanctions for his state,this servant of Sonia Gandhi,Manmohan Singh, granted a paltry amount of 800 crores and loftily said money does not grow on trees! Kashmiri Muslims are so lucky that our country is in the hands of traitors like the Congress party.If a referrundum is held today,Kashmiri Muslims will surely opt for India and not Pakistan.

S.S.Nagaraj
Bangalore, India
Order by
Order by
Short Takes
recent tags
1984 Anti-Sikh Riots
Ashok Mitra
BJP
Congress
Delhi - New Delhi
Gujarat: Riots 2002
Lok Sabha Elections
Manmohan Singh
Muslims
Narendra Modi
Prime Minister of India
 
bloggers
A. Sanzgiri
Boria Majumdar
Buzz
Dr Mohammad Taqi
Freya Dasgupta
G. Rajaraman
K.V. Bapa Rao
Maheshwer Peri
Namrata Joshi
News Ed
Omar Ali
Our Readers Write Back
Prarthna Gahilote
Shefalee Vasudev
Sundeep Dougal
ARCHIVES
Go
SMTWTFS
12345
6789101112
13141516171819
20212223242526
27282930
recent comments


ABOUT US | CONTACT US | SUBSCRIBE | ADVERTISING RATES | COPYRIGHT & DISCLAIMER | COMMENTS POLICY

OUTLOOK TOPICS:    a b c d e f g h i j k l m n o p q r s t u v w x y z  0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9   
Or just type in a few initial letters of a topic: